What You Need to Know Before Picking Up This Book
A Study in Charlotte is a mystery novel by Brittany Cavallaro that follows Violet Holmes, a descendant of Sherlock Holmes, and Charlotte Watson, a descendant of Dr. Watson, as they solve a murder at an academy modeled after Baskerville. The book came out in 2019 and became the first in a series. It mixes classic detective puzzle structure with boarding school setting and queer romance elements. I picked this up on a recommendation from a reader who knows my taste. They said if I liked locked-room mysteries with character dynamics that actually drive the plot, I should read it. I did. Here is what I found. The premise is straightforward. Two girls from very different backgrounds end up at an elite academy called Lockwood University. One carries the name Holmes and everyone expects her to be brilliant. The other carries the name Watson and is quietly competent without the fanfare. When a professor dies under suspicious circumstances, they are thrown together to investigate. The mystery itself is structurally sound, with fair-play clues and a resolution that rewards careful reading.
The book is 416 pages in the hardcover edition. Reading time for an average adult is about four to six hours depending on your pace. It is not a fast page-turner in the thriller sense, but it does not drag either. The pacing is measured, which fits the genre. One thing to be aware of before you commit. The romance subplot is central to the story and develops gradually. If you are looking for pure detective puzzle without character relationship development, this might not land well for you. I personally prefer when romance and mystery are woven together rather than kept separate, and this book does that reasonably well. But I know some readers treat those elements as distinct categories and would rather have one or the other done fully. The sequel, A Conspiracy of Paper, picks up immediately after the first book and is worth reading if you finish the first and are not annoyed by the ending. The third book, A Game of Secrets, continues the series and rounds out the main arc. I finished all three in a weekend. The series improves slightly with each installment as Cavallaro gets more comfortable balancing multiple plot threads.
If you want to read it, you can find it at major booksellers or through library systems. The ISBN for the hardcover is 978-1534421564. E-book and audiobook versions are also available from most retailers.
Get the Full Details
