How the Cooks Illustrated Macaroni And Cheese Method Actually Works
The Cooks Illustrated Macaroni And Cheese method is essentially a béchamel-based pasta bake that sidesteps the most common failure point in homemade mac and cheese: grainy, broken sauce. Most home cooks try to melt shredded cheese directly into hot pasta water or cream, which fails because cheese proteins tighten at high heat and squeeze out fat. The result is a greasy puddle with clumps of congealed protein. Cooks Illustrated figured this out years ago and published a method that uses a proper roux-thickened milk base, then incorporates the cheese off the heat at a controlled temperature. Here is how the process goes. You cook elbow macaroni in salted water until just shy of al dente, about 5 to 6 minutes for standard dried pasta. You drain it and set it aside. In the same pot, you melt butter, whisk in an equal amount of flour, and cook the roux for about a minute until it loses its raw flour taste. Then you slowly pour in whole milk while whisking constantly, bringing it to a gentle simmer until the sauce thickens enough to coat the back of a spoon. This usually takes around 5 minutes. At that point you remove the pot from the heat, let it cool for roughly 30 seconds, and stir in your cheese. The target sauce temperature at cheese incorporation is somewhere between 140 and 150 degrees Fahrenheit. Any hotter and the sauce will break. Any cooler and the cheese won't melt properly into the emulsion.
Cooks Illustrated Macaroni And Cheese breakdown
The cheese choice matters more than most people realize. A single cheese like sharp cheddar will give you flavor but poor melt. The method calls for combining a good melting cheese like Gruyère or Fontina with a flavorful hard cheese like aged cheddar or Parmigiano-Reggiano. The ratio I've settled on is roughly two parts melting cheese to one part flavor cheese by weight. Grate your own cheese. Pre-shredded cheese is coated in potato starch or cellulose to prevent clumping, and that coating actively prevents smooth melting. I learned this the hard way during a test batch where the sauce came out slightly grainy despite following every other step correctly. It took me ten minutes to figure out that the bagged cheese was the culprit. I switched to a box grater and block cheese and the sauce was instantly smooth. Once the cheese is melted into the sauce, you combine it with the drained pasta and transfer everything to a baking dish. Some versions call for a breadcrumb topping and a brief bake at 375 degrees Fahrenheit for about 20 minutes until bubbly. Others skip the bake entirely and serve immediately. The baked version gives you texture contrast but carries the risk of overcooking the pasta if you started it too far underdone. The no-bake version is riskier on the sauce side because the residual heat from the pasta and sauce continues to cook things slightly after mixing. One counter-intuitive thing about this method that beginners consistently miss: you should slightly undercook the pasta before adding it to the sauce. If you're going to bake it, cook the macaroni about 2 minutes less than the package directions say. The pasta will finish cooking in the hot sauce and then again in the oven. If you start with fully cooked pasta, the final texture tends toward mushy. The sauce also clings better to slightly firmer pasta because the starch on the surface is still active and can absorb some of the liquid.
Another detail that isn't obvious: the ratio of roux to liquid. Cooks Illustrated uses about 2 tablespoons of butter and flour for every cup of milk. That might seem like a lot of roux for a mac and cheese sauce, but it's necessary because the cheese addition thins the sauce considerably. If you skimp on the roux, you end up with a watery product that pools at the bottom of the dish. I once tried cutting the flour in half to make a lighter sauce and the result was soup, not cheese sauce. went back to the original ratio and it was fine. The main downside of this method is time. From start to finish, including prep, cooking pasta, making the béchamel, and baking, you're looking at about 45 minutes to an hour. That is significantly longer than the stovetop shortcut method where you just dump cheese into hot pasta. For a weeknight meal, that might be a dealbreaker. If you need something fast, a dried cheese sauce mix or a simple stovetop approach with a roux and evaporated milk will get you results in 15 minutes, even if the texture and flavor are inferior. The Cooks Illustrated method is worth it for weekend cooking or when you are feeding a group and want something that actually holds together on the plate without separating into oil and curds. If you do bake it, let the dish rest for about 5 minutes after pulling it out of the oven. This allows the sauce to reset and thicken slightly so it holds its shape when you scoop it. Serve it immediately. Leftovers reheat fine in the microwave with a splash of milk stirred in, but the texture will never quite match the fresh version because the pasta continues to absorb moisture and the emulsion gradually breaks down over time.
Get the Full Details
