Reading Crush By Cathy Cassidy Without Wasting Your Time
Cathy Cassidy's novel Crush came out in 2014 and follows sixteen-year-old Kate as she navigates high school romance, friendship drama, and the general messiness of being a teenager who has everything figured out except her own love life. It's middle-grade/YA crossover fiction, written in first-person present tense with short, punchy chapters that move fast. Not much depth underneath, but it does what it's supposed to do. I picked it up because a student asked me about it — the teacher had assigned it as a paired novel and half the class was complaining. I read it over an afternoon just to get a sense of what the assignment looked like. Here's what I found and how to work with it.
Crush By Cathy Cassidy: Where to Get It
The book is available through most major retailers and library systems. Penguin Random House published the hardcover first edition. It's also widely available as an ebook and audiobook if your audience prefers those formats. If you're a teacher ordering copies, the bulk pricing through Scholastic or Ingram is usually better than buying individually from Amazon. If you're a parent, the paperback from Costco or Walmart runs about seven to nine dollars depending on the edition. Libraries carry it consistently. I've never seen a waitlist longer than two weeks for it, which tells you something about demand. It's not a phenomenon-level read, but it's steady.
What Actually Happens in the Book
Kate is popular, beautiful, and seems to have it all together. She hangs out with her group of friends at school. She thinks she's in love with a guy named Max, who is charming but ultimately self-centered and not worth the energy. The plot moves through a series of social events — parties, school dances, misunderstandings — and Kate gradually realizes that Max isn't who she thought he was and that her friendships need more honesty than she's been giving them. The book is roughly 288 pages. The reading level sits around 6.5 to 7.5 on standard metrics, though the themes are squarely aimed at younger teens. It's not challenging but it's not empty either. Kate's voice is recognizable and consistent, which matters more in books like this than any thematic complexity. I've noticed that readers who go in expecting heavy emotional drama tend to be underwhelmed. This isn't that kind of book. It's a straightforward coming-of-age story with a clear arc and a resolution that doesn't leave much ambiguity. Some people don't like that. Others find it exactly what they need when they're not in the headspace for something complicated.
Get the Full Details
Common Pitfalls When Assigning or Reading This Book
The biggest issue I've run into is the pacing assumption. Teachers sometimes give this book as a two-week novel study and wonder why students are finished in three days. The chapters average four or five pages each, and they're designed to be devoured quickly. If you want to stretch the reading, you need to build in discussion activities, not just assign more time. Otherwise students finish and then sit there for a week doing nothing. Another problem is the friendship dynamics. The social relationships in the book are realistic for the age group but some teachers report that certain scenes trigger actual classroom conflict — kids taking sides, quoting dialogue back at each other in the hallway. I had one instance where two students got into a minor argument over whether a character's behavior was justified. It wasn't a big deal but it did derail a discussion period. I just redirected to the author's intent and moved on. The romance angle also doesn't age perfectly for some readers. Max comes across as a pretty standard jerk character, and Kate's realization about him is predictable from about page sixty. If your audience is already familiar with the genre, they'll spot the beats early. That's not necessarily a flaw in the book but it's worth acknowledging if you're using it with older or more experienced young readers.
What Works Well About It
The voice is the main thing. Cassidy writes Kate in a way that feels like an actual sixteen-year-old thinking through problems in real time. The dialogue isn't stilted. The internal monologue is coherent. For reluctant readers or students who need a quick win before moving to something longer, this does exactly that. It builds reading stamina without overwhelming anyone. The structure also makes it easy to pair with other texts. I've used it alongside short articles about social media pressure, basic essay writing exercises where students analyze Kate's choices, and even simple creative writing prompts where students write their own version of a key scene. The versatility is one of its stronger features.
When This Book Won't Work
If your goal is literary analysis or deep thematic exploration, this isn't the book. It's genre fiction for young adults, and it stays firmly in that lane. The prose doesn't do anything particularly inventive. The character development is functional rather than profound. If you need students to practice close reading or argumentative analysis, you'd be better served by something with more texture. Cathy Cassidy has written other books that touch on heavier subjects like body image in Wrecked or family breakdown in Runaway — those would be stronger choices for that purpose. The book also assumes a baseline familiarity with high school social structures. Readers who aren't in that environment or who come from very different cultural contexts may find the setting a bit remote. It's not a dealbreaker but it's something to keep in mind if your audience is diverse. Ultimately, Crush By Cathy Cassidy is a solid entry point. It does what it says on the cover, it reads quickly, and it doesn't treat its audience like they need to be lectured. It's not going to change anyone's life but it's honest about what it is. That's more than you can say for a lot of books in this category.
