What a Bible Cake Actually Is
A Bible cake is a traditional British bun that dates back at least to the 18th century, when it was commonly sold as a inexpensive street food. The classic version is a ring-shaped yeast bun made from milk bread dough, heavily spiced with allspice and caraway, studded with raisins or sultanas, and typically decorated with a cross piped onto the top using a thin white icing before baking. They are distinct from Simon Buns only in minor regional variations of spice ratios and shape. I have baked dozens of versions over many years and the consistent pattern is that most recipes online skip details that matter — like how the allspice quantity directly affects whether the interior tastes like a proper Bible cake versus just spiced tea bread. Start with about 500 grams of strong white bread flour, 7 grams of instant yeast, 10 grams of caster sugar, and 10 grams of salt. The liquid is warm milk and water roughly 250ml total, with 50 grams of softened butter worked into the dough after the initial mix. The critical detail here is that the butter must be cold enough to stay in discrete pieces during mixing rather than coating every flour particle — this creates those irregular pockets of steam that make the crumb tender without turning the whole thing dense. If you cream the butter into the flour first the result is more like a scone than a bun and the texture is fundamentally wrong for a Bible cake. Add roughly 100 grams of raisins or sultanas and 2 teaspoons of ground allspice plus 1 teaspoon of ground caraway seeds. Some bakers also include a pinch of mace or freshly grated nutmeg but I find that either is fine. The fruit should be tossed in a little flour first so it does not sink to the bottom of the bowl and then distributed evenly through the dough. Knead on a floured surface for about 10 minutes until smooth and elastic. Then place the dough in a lightly oiled bowl, cover, and leave to rise in a warm spot until doubled in volume — usually 60 to 90 minutes depending on ambient temperature. I once left mine in a drafty kitchen at about 12 degrees Celsius and it took nearly three hours which is not unusual but worth noting if your kitchen runs cold.
How To Make A Bible Cake Step By Step
After the first rise turn the dough onto a floured surface and divide it into 12 equal portions — about 70 to 75 grams each if your total dough weight is around 900 grams after all additions. Roll each piece into a smooth ball by cupping your hand over it and rotating on the counter. Arrange the balls in a greased 23-centimetre round tin or on a lined baking sheet, leaving a small gap between each so they expand without merging into one another. Cover loosely with oiled cling film or a damp tea towel and leave for a second proof — again about 45 to 60 minutes until puffy and nearly doubled. While they proof preheat your oven to 200 degrees Celsius fan forced or 220 degrees Celsius conventional. The higher the initial heat the better the oven spring and the more open the crumb will be. Before baking the cross decoration is piped on using a thin paste of plain flour and water or egg white and sugar — roughly 2 tablespoons of flour mixed with just enough liquid to form a smooth but not runny consistency. The cross should be thick enough to hold its shape through baking but thin enough that it does not form a hard crust. Some bakers use royal icing but I find the flour-and-water paste gives a more authentic historic result and avoids the cloying sweetness of modern decorations. Score a shallow cross into the top of each bun with a sharp knife before piping if you want a clearer visual anchor but the piped icing alone is sufficient.
Baking and Cooling
Bake for about 18 to 22 minutes until deeply golden brown and sounding hollow when tapped on the base. If the tops are browning too quickly tent loosely with aluminium foil after the first 12 minutes — I have found that ovens vary considerably and a fan oven at 200 degrees can sometimes over-colour the surface before the interior is fully cooked. The internal temperature should reach at least 90 degrees Celsius measured with a probe thermometer inserted into the centre of one bun. Cool on a wire rack for at least 20 minutes before eating — fresh from the oven the crumb is still setting and the texture is gummy rather than light. I once cut into a batch too early and the result was dense and unpleasant which is not a great look at a bakery counter. The most frequent mistake is under-spicing — Bible cakes should taste distinctly of allspice and caraway, not just raisin bread. If you halve the allspice quantity the result is bland and does not resemble a proper Bible cake at all. Another issue is over-proofing which makes the buns flat and dense rather than tall and airy. The dough is ready when it springs back slowly from a gentle press rather than holding the indentation. Over-baking dries out the crumb and makes the crust tough — the ideal Bible cake has a slightly crisp exterior with a soft moist interior. Store in an airtight container for up to three days or freeze for longer term preservation. They do not keep well more than a few days even sealed because the spice flavour fades and the crumb stales. I recommend eating within 48 hours for the best result. If you want a richer version add an extra 25 grams of butter and an egg to the dough but this moves closer to a brioche-style bun which is not traditional. A plain milk bread dough with the correct spice ratio is the right baseline. Some modern recipes add cinnamon or ginger but I find that obscures the allspice-forward character that defines the style. The historically accurate version relies almost entirely on allspice with caraway as a supporting note. Adjust to taste but do not stray too far from that balance.
Get the Full Details
