Searching for If You Lived With The Cherokees
Most people who look for this are either teachers planning a unit on Native American history or parents who want their kids to read something more honest than the standard textbook version. The book you want is called If You Lived When the Cherokees Were Removed by Ann Markusen and David Corn. It is part of a series that takes kids through major moments in American history by showing what daily life was actually like. The Cherokee volume covers the years before the forced removal and then the removal itself. It is aimed at upper elementary to middle school readers, roughly grades 4 through 8. The book is structured around a series of second-person vignettes. You are put in the shoes of a Cherokee child and shown the routine: farming, hunting, schooling, family structure, the impact of whiskey traders, and then the legal battles that followed. The tone is matter-of-fact. It does not shy away from the horror of the Trail of Tears but it does not dramatize it either. That restraint is actually one of its strengths. The death toll comes through clearly without needing embellishment.
What You Need to Know About If You Lived With The Cherokees
I used this book with a seventh-grade class a few years ago and ran into a problem most educators do not anticipate. Several students came to me afterward saying they thought the book was fictional because it was written in second person. They could not parse that the narrative voice was a teaching device, not a claim that the story was invented. I spent twenty minutes explaining that this is a common historical technique used across the entire series, and it probably would have been better if the book had a brief author note at the front clarifying the approach. It does not have one. The subtitle says nonfiction but the prose style makes it read like historical fiction to some kids. If you are using this in a classroom, you need to address that directly in lesson one or you will lose a chunk of your audience who dismiss the whole thing as made up. There is also a secondary issue with how the book handles the pre-removal period. It spends a significant amount of time on Cherokee achievements in agriculture, writing, and governance. That is important context. What it does not do as well is explain the internal political divisions within the Cherokee Nation that made removal possible. The Treaty of New Echota was signed by a faction that did not represent the majority of the tribe. Without understanding that fracture, students tend to view the removal as something done purely by external forces rather than a complex collision of internal politics, federal pressure, and white settlement demands. I supplemented the book with a short reading on Major Ridge and John Ross. It took ten minutes and filled a gap that the book leaves open. You can find the book through most major retailers. It is published by Clarion Books. The ISBN is 0395869673 for the first edition. If you want a PDF or digital copy, those tend to show up on educational resource sites and library databases rather than commercial platforms. I have seen it on some teacher sharing sites but those are usually unofficial uploads. The library route is cleaner. WorldCat will tell you which public libraries near you have it in stock. For schools, many districts already have copies through their literacy collections. I got one through our district library system with no trouble.
The companion materials are sparse. There is no official teacher guide from the publisher, which is a missed opportunity for a book aimed squarely at classrooms. You will need to build your own questions and activities. The reading level is manageable for most seventh graders, but some students will struggle with the pacing since the book jumps between topics quickly. I recommend having them keep a timeline as they read. It forces them to slow down and organize the sequence of events, which also helps with retention. Without that structure, they will finish the book and remember fragments rather than a coherent picture of what happened. One more practical point. The illustrations by David Corn are period-appropriate but sometimes ambiguous about clothing and tool details. If you are doing a visual literacy lesson alongside the reading, you should pair it with sources like the Library of Congress Cherokee collection so students can compare the book's depictions with actual historical photographs and artwork. That alone adds a layer of critical thinking that most teachers skip over.
Get the Full Details
