How to Play James Taylor's "You Can Close Your Eyes"
This is one of those songs that sounds way more complicated than it actually is. The harmony goes somewhere nice because Taylor is a master of voice leading, but the chord shapes themselves are basic open-position stuff. If you can play a D, a G, and an A7, you already know the bulk of this song. The artistry is in the rhythm and the way the lines move, not in exotic voicings. The standard tuning, D major key (some players capo 2 to sing along with the record). Here are the main shapes you need: D — xx0232
G — 320003
A7 — x02020
Em — 022000
Bm — x2443x
A — x02220
That's honestly most of what you need. The song mostly cycles through D, G, and A7. Everything else is color passing harmony. The verse progression runs like this: D G D A7. Two bars each, roughly. You strum it in a folk pattern or fingerpick it. The chorus adds a Bm for some minor color: D Bm G A7. Simple enough on paper. The real question is how you make it sound like James Taylor instead of a bar textbook. Here's where people mess it up. They play the chords as solid block strokes and it sounds flat. This song lives in the space between the beats. Taylor's right hand is constantly in motion, even when he's not strumming. Try this: play the D, let it ring, pick the bass string on beat three, then hit the full chord on the downbeat of the next measure. That gives the progression its breathing room. It's not a strumming pattern so much as a walking bass line with occasional chords thrown in on top.
I had a student try to learn this a few years back and he kept rushing the D-to-G transition. He was plucking the bass note and trying to form the G shape at the same time, which meant he'd either miss the bass note or fumble the chord. The workaround was simple: play the bass note with your thumb on the downbeat, hold the D shape, then move your fingers to G on the "& of 2" — basically stagger the transition so your left hand isn't trying to do two things at once. It sounded better immediately. For the bridge area where the Bm comes in, don't use a full barre chord. It's not necessary and it changes the color. A partial Bm — x244xx or even just 024400 if you want to keep your fingers free — works fine. The original recording has a slightly thinner sound on those minor chords anyway, so you're matching the vibe rather than fighting it. One counter-intuitive thing about this song: the A7 is doing more work than it looks like it is. It's not just a dominant leading back to D. In the context of this progression, the A7 creates tension against the G chord that follows it. If you replace A7 with a plain A, the whole thing loses its wistful quality. Keep the A7. The Fnote in there is doing heavy lifting emotionally, even if it's just one finger.
Get the Full Details
Here's another thing beginners miss. The chord voicings matter more than you'd expect. Open D and open G sound fine, but if you add the high D string on your G chord (320003 instead of 320000), it opens up the upper harmonics and makes the transition to A7 sound smoother. The extra note on the high E string also lets you pick out a melodic counter-line while you're waiting for the next chord change. It's a small change but it makes the whole arrangement feel less like a chord chart and more like a song. Timing-wise, the song sits around 68 to 72 BPM in 4/4. Not too slow, not too fast. If you're playing along with the record and struggling to keep up, slow the track down to 0.8x speed and practice the chord changes in isolation first. Don't try to play the whole thing at full tempo from the start. It takes longer and you cement bad habits. The downside of learning this as written is that it can sound a bit dry if you just play straight chords. The song benefits from dynamics — you want to play the verse softer and bring it up a bit in the chorus. Try not to hit every strum equally hard. That's probably the biggest difference between sounding like you're playing chords and sounding like you're playing a song.
If you want a reference, the official chord chart from James Taylor's songbook matches what I've laid out here. capo 2 if you're singing along with the album version, otherwise straight D tuning works for performance. The tab sites online mostly get it right, though some forget the A7 substitution and just write A, which changes the feel noticeably. Bottom line: the chords aren't hard. The feel is. Spend more time on your right hand and your dynamics than you do learning new shapes. This song is already in the first position. What separates a good version from a great one is almost entirely in how you treat the space between the chords.
