Understanding Me Not by Coleen Murtagh Paratore
Me Not is a picture book written and illustrated by Coleen Murtagh Paratore, published by Scholastic. It follows a young child who systematically tells the reader that they are not various things — not a monster, not scary, not something to be afraid of. The book uses repetitive negation as a structural device, which makes it useful in early literacy instruction for teaching vocabulary, sentence patterns, and the concept of contradiction. The text runs on a simple premise repeated across roughly twenty spreads. Each page presents an image and a line stating what the narrator is not. The illustrations show the child doing ordinary kid things — drawing, playing, riding a bike — while the text denies increasingly absurd identities. The humor comes from the gap between what the child is doing and what the reader might assume based on surface cues. I've used this book in reading groups more times than I can count, mostly with first and second graders who are still working through decoding and comprehension. The repetitive structure gives struggling readers a predictable pattern to latch onto. That said, the book has limitations you should know about before building a whole lesson around it.
The vocabulary is accessible but not trivial. Words like "monster," "scary," "afraid," and "happy" appear alongside slightly less common terms like "pretend" and "believe." For English language learners, the negation pattern can actually create confusion rather than clarity. I had a student once who kept answering "yes" to every question because she latched onto the rhythm of the sentences without processing the word "not." She'd read "I am not a monster" and nod along as if it said "I am a monster." The fix was simple — I had her highlight or circle every instance of "not" in the text and read the book again with that visual cue. It took two sessions but resolved the issue completely.
How to Use This Book in Instruction
The most straightforward application is teaching the concept of opposites and negation. Have students identify what the character is not on each page, then ask what the character actually is based on the illustrations. This builds inference skills without requiring advanced decoding. Another approach is having students create their own "Me Not" pages. They write a sentence saying what they are not, then draw or illustrate what they actually are. This works well for writer's workshop in grades K through 2. The constraint of the format — negation followed by an implied positive — gives young writers a scaffold they can work within without feeling overwhelmed by an open-ended prompt. For phonics work, the book contains several short vowel patterns and common sight words. I typically pull out the sight words first — "not," "am," "a," "is" — and have students track them across pages. The repetition means these words appear frequently, which reinforces recognition without needing extra worksheets.
Get the Full Details
What the Book Doesn't Do Well
Don't expect deep literary analysis from this text. The plot is minimal, the themes are surface-level, and the narrative arc amounts to a child asserting their identity through denial. If you're looking for a book to use in a units on character development or theme analysis, this isn't it. It works best as a phonics and vocabulary tool, not as a novel study anchor text. Another issue: the humor lands differently depending on the reader. Some children find the repeated denials funny. Others find them frustrating or confusing, especially if they're still developing their understanding of negative statements. I've seen kids shut down mid-read when they realize the character keeps saying what they're not without ever clearly stating what they are. In those cases, stopping to explicitly list what the character actually is — using the pictures as evidence — helps re-engage them. The book is also short. At roughly thirty-two pages with large illustrations and sparse text, it reads in under ten minutes even for slow readers. That means you'll need to supplement it with additional activities if you want a full lesson or unit. The companion activities — the student-created pages, the vocabulary sort, the inference discussions — are where the instructional time actually lives, not in the reading itself.
Where to Find It
Me Not is available through Scholastic, Amazon, and most major book retailers. It's also widely stocked in school supply catalogs, so if you're ordering through a district procurement system, it may already be on a standing order. Used copies circulate readily on eBay and ThriftBooks if you're on a tight budget. Scholastic sometimes offers classroom sets at a discount, which is worth checking if you need multiple copies for a reading group. The book is also available in some library systems, so a quick Interlibrary Loan request could get you a copy within a week if that's preferable to purchasing.
