The One Dough Ratio I Actually Use
Flour: 100%. Water: 70% (of flour weight). Salt: 2%. Starter or yeast: 20% active starter or 0.8% instant yeast. That's it. Nothing else matters for basic bread. I stopped writing recipes down years ago and just kept a spreadsheet of percentages. You can scale any of these numbers up or down and the math stays identical. Here's the quick reference I keep open on my phone while mixing: Hydration levels: 60% = stiff dough, handles like clay, good for bagels and pretzels. 65% = workable sourdough. 70% = stretchy and forgiving, this is where most people land. 75% = shaggy and messy, demands confidence. 80%+ = cofee batter territory, requires a banneton and a plan.
Mixing time by method: Autolyse 30 minutes minimum before adding salt and leaven. Bulk fermentation at 75°F takes 4–5 hours. At 80°F expect 3–4 hours. At 65°F you're looking at 8+ hours. Cold retard overnight works at any of these temperatures; it just changes the flavor profile. Baking temps: 450°F with steam for crust. 425°F without steam for softer crust. Dutch oven or cloche captures your own steam for the first 20 minutes, then vent or remove to finish. Preheating the pot for 45 minutes minimum matters more than most people realize. I once tried an 82% hydration dough using whole wheat flour and it spread into a pancake on the baking stone. The problem wasn't the hydration number itself — whole wheat absorbs more water than white flour but also develops less gluten structure at high hydration. I switched to a 75% hydration with 30% whole wheat instead and got a proper loaf. The workaround is simpler than people think: dial back the water when you increase the whole grain percentage, and add an extra 10 minutes of bulk fermentation to give the enzymes time to build strength.
Why People Mess This Up
The biggest mistake isn't the ratio. It's treating every flour as interchangeable. King Arthur bread flour and Bob's Red Mill bread flour absorb different amounts of water even when they're both labeled "bread flour." I learned this the hard way when a batch came out dense after I swapped brands mid-week. The fix is weighing your flour and adjusting water by 5% increments until the dough feels right. The dough should pull away from the bowl slightly during the first few stretches but still feel tacky. If it tears when you stretch it, it needs more time. If it slumps immediately, it needs less water next time. Another thing nobody mentions enough: room temperature varies across your kitchen. The spot near the oven is often 5–10°F warmer than the corner table. I keep a cheap digital thermometer clipped to my bulk fermentation bowl now. Without one, you're guessing, and guessing is how you get over-proofed bread at 2 PM when you wanted it ready at dinner.
Get the Full Details
When This Approach Breaks
A minimalist cheat sheet does not work for enriched doughs like brioche, challah, or cinnamon rolls. Those need butter, eggs, sugar, and different hydration calculations. The 70% water rule collapses the moment you add fat because fat coats the flour proteins and changes gluten development entirely. If you want those breads, you need a separate set of ratios. The minimalist approach also struggles with multigrain loaves that include oats, rye, or seeds — those ingredients compete for water and throw off your hydration math unless you pre-soak them separately. Pour over
