So You Want to Make a Chicken Pie Without Fumbling Through the Box
Most people stare at the back of a Mrs Pumpkins frozen pie card and wonder why the instructions read like they were written by a lawyer who's never cooked. The temperature numbers are right, but the timing assumptions assume you're working with an electric oven that actually knows what it's doing. My first attempt I pulled it out after 28 minutes and the pastry was still doughy at the seam. That's because every oven runs hot or cold, and the manual doesn't account for that. Here's what actually works. Preheat to 200°C fan / 220°C conventional. Put the pie on a baking tray because it will bubble, and it will bubble over the sides if you put it straight on the rack. Slide it into the middle shelf and set a timer for 30 minutes. After that, check the centre temperature with a digital probe — it needs to hit 75°C. If you don't have a probe, cut a small slit at the thickest part and let steam escape for five seconds, then taste a bit of the filling. For the last five minutes, if the pastry isn't browning, flip the grill on for three or four minutes watching closely. I know this from personal experience: the top will burn before the bottom is cooked if you just rely on the stated time. My workaround is to tent a piece of foil loosely over the top at the 25-minute mark, then remove it for the final browning. This gives you even cooking through the filling without the crust turning into charcoal.
The real pitfall nobody mentions is that the pie comes out of the freezer at roughly minus 18°C and sits there until you put it in the oven. If your kitchen is cold, the thermal shock is worse. Letting it sit on the counter for 10 minutes before baking makes a measurable difference in how evenly the centre cooks. It won't thaw fully, but it sheds the extreme surface cold that makes the outer pastry overcook while the middle stays icy. There's also the issue of the filling ratio. Some batches of Mrs Pumpkins chicken pie run wetter than others, which means more liquid pooling under the pastry. If your bottom crust looks soggy after removing from the oven, you can salvage it by popping the pie under a hot grill for two minutes to dry it out, or by transferring the filling to a saucepan and reducing it while reheating the base separately. It's not ideal but it beats eating a raw-dough bottom. One more thing worth noting: these instructions assume a standard 300g pie. If you're making something larger or smaller from their range, the time scales poorly. A 400g variant needs roughly another eight minutes, and I've found that adding minutes isn't linear — the centre takes longer than you'd expect. For bigger pies, bump the initial cook to 35 minutes, check the core temperature, then adjust in five-minute increments rather than guessing by the clock alone.
If you want something faster, microwave it for four minutes then finish under the grill for two. The texture won't match the full oven method, but for a quick weeknight meal it cuts the time in half and the result is acceptable. That said, the full bake is genuinely better for the pastry structure, so I only use the shortcut when I'm genuinely rushed.
Get the Full Details
