Making a Pinecone Bird Feeder Is Easier Than You Think
The basic method involves coating a pinecone in something sticky like peanut butter or shortening, then rolling it in birdseed. Hang it outside and wait for birds to show up. That is the entire thing. It sounds almost too simple because it is. Here is how I actually do it, not the romanticized version you see on craft blogs. Gather natural pinecones from your yard or a local wooded area. You want ones that are fully closed - tight scales mean the seed stays inside longer. Open cones tend to shed seed everywhere within hours. If you find open cones, you can gently warm them on a baking sheet at 200 degrees Fahrenheit for ten minutes to encourage the scales to close back up before you start. Now, about the binder. Peanut butter works, but I prefer unsweetened, unflavored peanut butter because added sugar and salt actually repel some bird species. The cheap processed stuff with hydrogenated oils is fine for cardinals and chickadees, but goldfinches and nuthatches turn their noses up at it. Shortening is the alternative I reach for when I want something less likely to go rancid in heat. It holds up better in direct sun than peanut butter does.
Coat the cone thoroughly, working the stuff into every gap between scales. Roll it in seed mix - my go-to is a blend of black oil sunflower seeds and millet. Suet chips work too if you break them into small pieces first. The key is pressing the seed into the binder rather than just rolling it lightly over the surface. Light rolling means the seed falls off in the first rain or from a heavy bird landing. Press it in. Attach a piece of twine or jute to hang it. Wrap it around the base of the cone and tie a loop at the top. Don't use wire - it cuts into the scales and looks ugly. Cotton twine degrades naturally over a season, which is fine because you are making new ones anyway. I hung my first batch out in late March and had a downy woodpecker on it within twenty minutes. By the second week, I had titmice, chickadees, and a goldfinch all using the same feeder. The suet-chip version attracted the woodpeckers fastest. The regular seed mix held up through a light rain without disintegrating, which surprised me since pinecones absorb water like sponges. However, after a heavy downpour, the inner scales did start to soften and the whole thing became structurally weak. I learned to bring them inside or use a covered porch after any substantial rainfall.
One edge case that caught me off guard: squirrels. They will strip a pinecone feeder clean in minutes if they know it is there. My workaround was wrapping a section of the cone's middle with a strip of poultry netting before applying the binder. The squirrels can't get past the mesh, but small birds slip right through the openings. It takes about thirty seconds extra to prepare each cone and makes the feeder look slightly less natural, but it completely solves the squirrel problem without needing any expensive hardware or complex mechanisms. Storage matters more than people expect. If you make a bunch at once and they sit in a hot garage, the peanut butter will go rancid within a week. Shortening lasts longer but still degrades. Keep unused feeders refrigerated and they hold for about two weeks. For long-term storage, freeze them in airtight bags - they keep for months. Just let them come to room temperature before hanging so condensation doesn't form on the seed coating. The total cost per feeder comes to roughly fifteen to twenty-five cents if you are gathering pinecones yourself. Commercial pre-made pinecone feeders run three to five dollars each at garden centers, so the DIY route saves significant money if you are making more than a handful. The time investment is about five to ten minutes per cone from gathering to hanging.
Get the Full Details
Seasonal timing is worth noting. These feeders work best from early spring through late fall. In deep winter, birds need higher-calorie food sources and a pinecone with surface-level seed doesn't provide enough nutrition compared to a proper platform or tube feeder filled with dense seed. I stop putting them out once consistent freezing temperatures set in and switch to heated bird baths and indoor feeders instead. Come February, the cones would just freeze solid and become useless.
What Birds Actually Use These
Chickadees and titmice are the most reliable visitors. Nuthatches come in regularly. Goldfinches prefer the thistle and sunflower seed versions. Cardinals and jays will use them but they are too heavy and often break the twine or damage the cone structure. Squirrels will use them as a food source whether you want them to or not, which is why the poultry netting trick exists. Hummingbirds won't touch these at all. Woodpeckers, especially downy and hairy species, are the ones you are most likely to see first. They cling to the cone and hammer at it to get to the seed trapped between the scales.
