What the Slavery By Another Name Worksheet Actually Covers
The worksheet revolves around Douglas A. Blackmon's book Slavery By Another Name, which documents the convict leasing system that replaced chattel slavery in the American South from roughly 1865 to World War II. The material deals with court records, prison contracts, and the systematic criminalization of Black freedom. Students typically analyze primary source documents, answer guided questions about state laws and corporate involvement, and compare pre-war and post-emancipation conditions. I use this in college survey courses and occasionally in AP US History prep sessions.Slavery By Another Name Worksheet: How to Use It in Class
Here's how the worksheet generally works in practice. You distribute the primary source excerpts alongside the guided questions. Students work individually or in small groups, then reconvene for discussion. The real learning happens during the debrief, where students realize that the legal mechanisms described were explicit, written, and widely enforced. I assign the worksheet after students read chapters one through three. The questions typically ask them to identify specific statutes, calculate financial figures from leasing contracts, and explain how local law enforcement participated. One thing beginners consistently miss is that the lease contracts often listed exact prices per prisoner per day. The numbers are brutal when you actually compute them. I've had students balk when they realize companies were paying twenty to thirty cents per day per man, which translates to roughly six to nine dollars per month, and then profiting far more than that by denying food and medical care. That calculation alone shifts the entire discussion.The download link for the standard version of the Slavery By Another Name Worksheet is usually available through university education department pages or educational resource repositories like EdHelper and Teachers Pay Teachers. I recommend checking your institution's library database first, since those versions often have better source documentation attached.
What Most Students Struggle With on This Worksheet
The hardest section involves the Alabama convict leasing data. Students tend to skim over the tables and miss the correlation between the state's fiscal dependence on leased labor and the severity of its black codes. I walk them through one specific table line at a time. The pattern becomes obvious quickly, but only if you slow down. Another common issue is the terminology. The worksheet uses terms like "peonage" and "apprenticeship" alongside "convict leasing," and students conflate them. They're related but distinct legal mechanisms. Peonage involved debt bondage that trapped workers. Apprenticeship laws allowed courts to place Black children under white guardianship for trivial offenses. Convict leasing specifically rented prisoners to private companies. The overlap is intentional in Blackmon's argument, but the worksheet questions won't mark you wrong if you distinguish them correctly.Edge Cases and Workarounds I've Run Into
One problem I encountered regularly was that some versions of the worksheet rely on court records from specific counties, and the digitized sources vary wildly in quality. In one semester, my students were working from a scanned transcript where roughly forty percent of the names were illegible due to poor archival preservation. That made the demographic analysis question nearly impossible to complete accurately. I solved this by switching to the Documenting the American South archive at the University of North Carolina, which has a cleaner transcription of the same Alabama circuit court records. The data matched, and the student work improved immediately.If you're assigning this independently and your source copy has degraded records, request the UNC version directly. The URL is docd.lib.unc.edu, and you can search for "convict lease" under Southern Historical Collection.
Counter-Intuitive Points Beginners Miss
First, the system was not a shadowy underground operation. It was publicly recorded, openly advertised in newspapers, and actively promoted by state governors. The governor of Alabama in the early 1900s personally negotiated lease contracts. That fact usually shocks students who assumed this was something hidden by history. Second, the economic scale was enormous. At its peak, the state of Alabama received approximately half its annual budget from convict leasing revenue. That figure comes directly from the worksheet's financial analysis section. When students see that number, the subsequent abolition of the system through legislative action in the late 1920s makes much more sense. It wasn't moral awakening that ended it. It was financial mismanagement and public scandal after a leased convict died on a Pennsylvania railroad contract.Limitations of the Worksheet
The main limitation is geographic narrowness. The standard worksheet focuses heavily on Alabama and a few other Deep South states. If your course covers the broader national picture, including northern complicity through banking and insurance connections to the leasing industry, you'll need supplementary materials. Blackmon addresses this in the book, but the worksheet itself doesn't always include those sections. I add readings from Eric Foner's reconstruction materials and the National Bureau of Economic Research papers on corporate involvement to round out the assignment. Another limitation is the emotional weight. This material is heavy. Students who are not prepared for graphic descriptions of violence and exploitation can have genuine distress responses. I always give a content warning before distributing the worksheet and make sure the classroom environment is set up so students can step out if needed. No point in pushing through trauma for a grade.Step-by-Step Breakdown
Download a current version of the Slavery By Another Name Worksheet. I prefer the one hosted on the Gilder Lehrman Institute site, which includes primary source documents with citations. Print double-sided to reduce paper waste. Distribute the first page covering the introduction and black code analysis before moving into the leasing contract questions. Allow forty minutes for individual work, then spend twenty minutes on group comparison. The final ten minutes should be reserved for the financial calculation exercise. That last part is where students typically do the most meaningful engagement with the material.If you want a quicker version for a single class period, skip the Appendix C questions on federal prosecution attempts and focus on sections one through four. You still cover the core argument without rushing the most important material.
Get the Full Details
