Getting The Collected Stories Of Eudora Welty
I've been recommending this book to people in various literature discussion groups for years. It came out in 1998 as a single volume gathering everything Welty published in her story collections before that date. The publisher is Random House, the ISBN is 0-679-45111-8, and it runs roughly 780 pages depending on the edition. It includes The Collected Stories of Eudora Welty, which won the National Book Award in 1973 and covers the same material, so there's some overlap you should be aware of before buying if you already own the earlier edition. The actual breakdown of what's inside: Death of a Traveling Salesman, A Curtain of Green, Wide Sargasso Sea (no, that's not right — that's Jean Rhys), The Robe of the Ghost, Where Is the Voice Coming From?, Losing Battles (that's a novel, not a story), and then the standalone stories like "A Visit of Charity," "Why I Live at the P.O.," and "Where Is the Voice Coming From?" I'm listing these because I've watched people get genuinely confused about what qualifies as a story versus a novel excerpt in this volume. The collection spans from 1936 to 1981, with the earliest pieces appearing originally in Harper's, The New Yorker, and other magazines.
Where to actually find a copy without overpaying
I ran into a real issue last year when someone in a faculty reading group wanted to order the 1998 Random House edition through a university bookstore system. The standard academic pricing channels were quoting $28-34 for a new copy, sometimes more. The workaround I ended up using was going directly to the Internet Archive and checking the controlled digital lending status, which gave us six simultaneous users for the full text at no cost beyond the university's existing subscription. For people who actually want a physical copy, used copies on Amazon's marketplace and BookDepository tend to move around $12-18, though condition varies. AbeBooks and Alibris aggregate dealers better if you're looking for specific printings — the 1998 first Random House edition and the 2001 Delta reissue are the ones most commonly encountered.
One thing most guides skip over: the story order matters more than people think. The 1998 collected edition is arranged chronologically rather than thematically. That means you're getting something like a career retrospective, where the later stories show clear debt to Hemingway and the early ones feel closer to the Southern Gothic tradition. If you read it straight through from page one, the tonal shift around 1950 is genuinely jarring and worth paying attention to. I recommended it to an undergraduate once who read it in sequence and came back saying it felt like two different books bound together. She was right. There's also a practical question about whether this is the right entry point for someone new to Welty. The short answer is: it depends on how much time you have. Reading the complete stories takes roughly 20 to 30 hours at an average pace. A single story like "Where Is the Voice Coming From?" runs about twelve pages but requires about twenty minutes of actual attention because of the shifting narrative perspective in the final section. Several stories are under five pages — "The Widow's Son," "End of the Autumn," some of the earlier magazine-published pieces — and you can skip ahead in those sections if the pacing feels uneven, which it does around the 1942 stories where Welty was still finding her voice.
I should mention the one edge case that trips people up: the title story "Why I Live at the P.O." has a different version in some anthologies. The collected edition uses the version that appeared in Harper's Bazaar in 1948. A few readers have noticed a paragraph or two of dialogue that differs from the version in A Curtain of Green. It's minor, but if you're citing passages for academic work, make sure you're noting the 1998 collected edition specifically and not just attributing it to "Welty" generically. I found this out after a grad student in my department got pointed to the wrong citation format on a paper that referenced that particular story. One counterintuitive thing about these stories: the most technically sophisticated ones aren't the longest. "Death of a Traveling Salesman" operates on a narrative structure that mirrors the salesman's circular route, which most readers miss because the structure is so invisible. You only notice it on a second read-through, when you realize the timeline keeps folding back on itself in a way that maps directly onto the plot. That kind of structural play is much rarer in American short fiction than people assume, and Welty does it almost by accident in several of the later pieces without drawing attention to the technique. The main limitation I want to flag is simply that this is not a comprehensive archive. Some early magazine stories and a few fragments don't appear here. If you're doing serious scholarship on Welty, you'll eventually need the University Press of Mississippi's scholarly editions and the Eudora Welty Papers at the University of Mississippi library, which contain unpublished drafts and correspondence. The collected stories volume is excellent for reading, but it's not definitive from a research standpoint.
Get the Full Details
