Why This Memoir Actually Works
The Color of Water by James McBride is part memoir, part family oral history, and honestly one of the more honest books about race in America that doesn't lecture you the whole time. McBride writes about his mother, Ruth, who was a white Jewish woman from Maryland, and his father, who was Black and left the family when McBride was young. He alternates between his own coming-of-age story and his mother's autobiography, which makes the structure a bit odd at first but ends up being the whole point. Ruth's sections come first in the book's framing device. She tells her story straight chronologically - growing up poor in the 1930s, marrying a Black man in the 1950s, raising twelve children in Harlem while working multiple jobs. Her voice is dry, funny, and unapologetic. McBride's sections fill in the gaps - what it was like actually living with that kind of intensity in a household that barely had money but had this fierce insistence on education and discipline. One thing most people miss on a first read is how central music is to the book. Ruth played piano, her husband was a gospel singer, and McBride himself becomes a musician. The color itself - the title - comes from McBride trying to describe his mother's skin tone, which was so light he couldn't find the right word for it. That's not a subtle metaphor. It's the whole thing compressed into one confused question a kid had about his own family.
I ran into a problem once trying to use this book in a high school curriculum. Some administrators pushed back on the language - it's raw in places, and Ruth swears a lot, which is frankly one of the reasons she feels real. My workaround was to assign the excerpts selectively rather than the whole text. The chapters where Ruth talks about her childhood in Alexandria and then her move to Harlem are the core. The McBride interludes about his own adolescence can be lightened depending on the class. That said, if you're teaching this to younger students, the frank discussion of racism and identity will come through loud and clear, which is exactly what makes it valuable. There's a counter-intuitive thing about this book that trips people up. It's easy to read it as purely an American race narrative, but it's equally a story about religion. Ruth was deeply spiritual in a way that didn't fit neatly into any single denomination. She prayed, she believed, but she wasn't dogmatic about any specific doctrine. McBride explores his own relationship with faith throughout the book, and neither of them lands in a comfortable place. That tension is deliberate. The book refuses to resolve it neatly, which some readers find unsatisfying. I think that refusal is the point. Another thing beginners often overlook: the structure isn't just stylistic flourishing. The alternating voices force you to hold two perspectives at once - a white Jewish woman's experience of prejudice and her son's experience of being racialized differently. Neither perspective cancels the other out. That's harder to sustain in practice than it sounds on paper, and McBride mostly pulls it off, though there are moments where the switch between voices feels slightly jarring rather than seamless.
The book does have limitations. It's selective in its memory. Ruth's autobiography section is her telling her story, which means it's filtered through her own biases and blind spots. McBride is writing about his own family, so there's inevitably a curatorial hand at work. Some critics have noted that the broader context of American history gets somewhat compressed to serve the personal narrative. This isn't a flaw per se - it's a memoir, not a textbook - but it's worth knowing if you're using this for anything beyond personal reading. If you want something that covers the historical ground more thoroughly, Deborah Gray White's work on Black women in America provides better structural context. But for the emotional truth of what it felt like to grow up in this specific family, this book is hard to beat. It's available through most major booksellers and libraries, and given the occasional debates about whether it should be taught in schools, it's been making the rounds again in recent years.
Get the Full Details
