Researching the Monterey Hotel History
A lot of people ask about the history of hotels in the Monterey area and end up confused because there have been multiple properties with similar names over the decades. I spent some time digging into this a while back, mostly because the record gets messy. The core issue is that "Monterey Hotel" has been used as a name for at least three distinct properties, and they're not always separated clearly in whatever archive you're looking at. If you're trying to trace what actually happened here, start by separating the properties by era. The earliest one people usually mean is the Hotel del Monte, which opened in 1880 near the eastern edge of downtown Monterey. It was a massive Gilded Age resort that drew railroad wealth, tennis players, and politicians. That building burned down in 1953, so any photographs or records from after that date aren't about the original structure. What remains today is the Monterey Bay Country Club, which occupies part of the grounds. The architecture firm was Kendall and Lyman, and the landscape design was by Frederick Law Olmsted Jr. Those details show up in the San Francisco Public Library's California History section if you need primary sources. Then there's the Hotel Monterey on Webster Street, which opened in the 1960s and operated as a mid-scale business hotel for most of its life. It closed in the early 2000s and the building was demolished. I ran into a problem when trying to verify the exact demolition date because the city of Monterey's permit records are split between two online systems — one for building permits and a separate one for demolition. They don't cross-reference. What I ended up doing was pulling the microfilm records from the Monterey County Recorder's office and matching the parcel number to the demolition filing. The permit came through in late 2003, and the actual wrecking ball hit the building sometime in early 2004. If you're just searching the web, you'll find conflicting dates ranging from 2001 to 2005 depending on which source you trust.
The third property is the building that used to house the historic Hotel Del Rio, which had various iterations. This one is even messier because ownership records get tangled with corporate restructuring in the 1970s. I personally hit a wall trying to trace the architect for the 1972 renovation. The county files list a firm that apparently dissolved in 1974, and their records were reportedly lost in a move. The workaround was to look at the construction contracts filed with the State Licensing Board — sometimes the general contractor's name shows up on those, and you can trace from there. The contractor in this case was a local firm called Pacific Coast Builders, and their project files at the California State Archives had the architectural stamp on the permit drawings. Here's something most people miss when researching these histories: newspaper archives are both the best and worst source. The Monterey Herald has decent coverage from 1890 onward, but their online database only goes back to about 1980. Before that, you need the physical microfilm. And the coverage is spotty for anything that isn't a scandal or a celebrity visit. A hotel opening or a routine renovation might get a single paragraph, if that. Cross-referencing with city directory records helps fill gaps, but those directories themselves have errors — owners' names get transposed, street addresses shift over time, and the alphabetical listings sometimes miss entries entirely. Another thing that trips people up is the confusion between the Hotel del Monte and what locals casually call "the Monterey Hotel." These are different places, and conflating them produces incorrect timelines. The del Monte was a luxury resort. The Webster Street Hotel Monterey was a no-frills business hotel. They served completely different markets and their architectural styles, guest demographics, and operational histories don't overlap in any meaningful way. When you're reading secondary sources, check whether the author knows this distinction. A lot of amateur history writing smushes them together.
If you want official documents, the Monterey Historic Preservation Commission keeps some records, but they're not fully digitized. Their staff can pull files by request, and a lot of the earlier permits and correspondence are on file there. The San Francisco Bay Area Research Center at the Bancroft Library also has some relevant material, particularly around the del Monte's early years and its relationship with the Southern Pacific Railroad, which was essential to its original success. Visit hours are limited and the reading room requires advance notice for box requests, so plan around that. The bottom line is that the history is there, but it's scattered across multiple institutions with different access policies. My recommendation is to start with the Bancroft for the 19th-century material and the city's own archives for anything post-1950. Don't trust a single source, and don't assume the dates you find online are accurate without checking the underlying record. The discrepancies aren't usually malicious — they're just the result of different people making different assumptions about which building they're talking about.
Get the Full Details
