Getting the Most Out of No More Mr. Nice Guy in Your Setlist

The Alice Cooper No More Mr Nice Guy album came out in 1977, and the title track remains one of the most covered hard rock songs when it comes to guitar tone and arrangement. I've played this song live probably two hundred times across various lineups, and I can tell you the thing most people get wrong isn't the solo — it's the rhythm tone and how they handle the pre-chorus transition. The original recording uses a Les Paul through a Marshall combo, but the key detail that gets missed is the amp is pushed pretty hard. If you're playing in a smaller venue with a lower volume ceiling, you need to compensate. I learned this the hard way at a club in Detroit where the sound guy was fighting me the entire night because my stage volume was bleeding into his vocal mics. The fix was switching to an attenuator — specifically a Radial HotPlate — which let me run the tube section of my amp at full power while keeping the actual output at a manageable level. Without that, the song just sounds thin and lifeless in the verses.

Alice Cooper No More Mr Nice Guy: Guitar Tone Setup

Here's what actually works. You want a humbucker pickup, bridge position, tone knob rolled back to about seven. Your gain structure should have the amp pushing into natural compression. The difference between a good version of this song and a mediocre one is almost entirely in the rhythm tone during the verses — that palm-muted opening riff needs to sound tight, not muddy. I used to leave my EQ flat and wonder why the mix never sat right. Rolling the bass down about two ticks from neutral and boosting mids slightly fixed that completely. The chorus opens up, so don't be afraid to let the volume ride. That's built into the song's dynamic. Play the verse quiet and restrained, then open the guitar volume knob up for the chorus. It's a subtle move but it does more for the feel than any pedal change would.

Bass and Drums: Where People Go Wrong

The bass line on this track is deceptively complex. It follows the chord changes but has these little fills between phrases that give the whole song its forward momentum. Most bass players just follow the root notes and the track falls apart. Listen to Michael Bruce's work on the original album — he's playing fills that sync with the vocal phrasing, not just the guitar. That's the part people miss. For drums, the trick is the half-time feel in the verses. It's not actually half-time, but it sits in that pocket between straight rock and a slower shuffle. If you push it too hard into a straight beat, it loses the swagger. If you drag it too far, it sounds lazy. The sweet spot is around 118 BPM feel, even though the tempo is closer to 105. You're counting in eighths but feeling in triplets. This is one of those things you just have to feel after playing it enough times.

Get the Full Details

Category:Alice Cooper - Ol’ Black Eyes Tour in 2019 - Wikimedia Commons
Category:Alice Cooper - Ol’ Black Eyes Tour in 2019 - Wikimedia Commons

What Doesn't Work

Don't layer too many distortion pedals on top of the amp. I've seen guitarists stack overdrive into distortion into fuzz and then wonder why the verses sound like a wall of noise that drowns out the vocals. The beauty of this song is the contrast between the gritty but controlled verses and the bigger, more open chorus. You lose that contrast if everything is at the same saturation level. Also avoid playing this song faster than the original tempo. Some bands try to speed it up to make it sound more aggressive, but it turns into a generic punk track and loses everything that makes the arrangement work. The song's power comes from its slouch — the deliberate, almost careless groove that Alice Cooper perfected in the studio. If you're recording this at home, the single biggest improvement you can make is getting the vocal timing right. The melody has these syncopated pushes against the beat that are easy to rush. I record myself playing along first, then learn the vocal rhythm separately before layering it in. Takes more time upfront but saves hours of fixing timing issues later.