Why Among Others By Jo Walton Actually Works (And Why It Won't For Everyone)
Most people approach Jo Walton's 2011 novel expecting a straightforward fantasy. It's not that simple. Morwen "Momo" Callanoch moves to rural Wales with her adoptive brother to get away from a troubled past, and slowly the book reveals that she can actually see and talk to fae creatures. The premise sounds cozy, but the execution is where things get interesting, and honestly, where a lot of readers either fall in love with it or bounce off hard. The book is structured as Momo's personal diary, which means you're reading her raw, unfiltered thoughts over what amounts to a couple of years. This narrative choice does two things at once. It makes the faerie encounters feel genuinely surprising because you discover what Momo can do at roughly the same pace she does, and it means the book never lets you forget she's fifteen and dealing with trauma, loneliness, and a complicated relationship with her dead mother. Some readers find the diary format tedious. They're not wrong. It's deliberate, but it's also a filter.
What Among Others By Jo Walton Actually Is
At its core, this is a coming-of-age story wrapped in a faerie narrative. The real subject is Momo's relationship with books, mathematics, and the communities she builds around them. Walton uses Welsh mythology and faerie lore as a framework, but the emotional engine of the book is about a girl finding her people. That's why it resonated so strongly with readers who felt like outsiders. The Hugo and Nebula Awards were well deserved, but don't let that convince you it's universally perfect. There are real structural choices here that create genuine friction. The first third of the book is deliberately slow. Momo arrives in Wales, sorts through books, and gradually encounters small faerie anomalies. If you're expecting action, you'll be frustrated for nearly a hundred pages. I learned this after preordering the hardcover and almost returning it at page sixty. The payoff comes, but you have to commit to the pace. One thing most reviews gloss over: the mathematics. Momo is genuinely smart about math, and Walton doesn't water this down or treat it as decoration. There are actual references to topological spaces and other concepts that matter to the plot. This isn't throwaway detail. A reader who dismisses the math as flavor text is missing how much of Momo's worldview is built on it. The faerie encounters themselves operate on logical rules that mirror mathematical reasoning. Understanding this connection changes how you read the magical scenes.
What Actually Happens In The Book (Without Spoilers)
Momo's mother, a mathematician and writer, dies young. Her father remarries, and the household becomes difficult. Momo ends up in Wales living with her brother Gruffudd and his partner. She finds a copy of Fairies by Walter Evans-Wentz in a used bookstore, and through that book she begins seeing the faerie folk who've been there all along. They're not the Tolkien version or the Disney version. Walton draws heavily from Welsh tradition, and the creatures are strange, dangerous, and indifferent rather than charming. There's also a subplot involving an online community of like-minded readers and fans. Walton knew exactly what she was doing when she wrote this. The book is, in part, about the specific kind of belonging that comes from shared intellectual and creative interests. Momo finds her "others" through books and mathematics and music, not through conventional social pathways. This is both the book's greatest strength and a limitation depending on what you want from fiction.
Get the Full Details
Common Pitfalls For New Readers
I've seen the same complaints cluster around this book repeatedly across forums and review sections, and most of them come from mismatches between expectation and reality rather than actual failures in the text. The first issue is pacing expectations. This is not a fast book. The faerie encounters build gradually, and the emotional weight accumulates slowly. Readers looking for plot propulsion will check out early. If you go in expecting a standard YA fantasy arc, you'll be confused when the climax is more emotional than action-based. The second issue is the diary format. Diaries are naturally repetitive. You re-read the same concerns, circle back to the same questions. Walton leans into this, and some readers find it exhausting. I found it realistic, but that's personal preference. There's no way around it other than accepting the format or moving on.
The third issue is the Welsh cultural specificity. Not all readers will connect with the Welsh setting and mythology, and Walton doesn't apologize for it. She's writing from a place of genuine familiarity and affection. If that language and tradition don't land for you, the book will feel narrower than it actually is. The universal themes are still there, but they're carried on Welsh cultural infrastructure.
Who Should Read This And Who Shouldn't
You'll probably enjoy this if you like books about readers, if you're interested in faerie folklore outside the Tolkien tradition, or if you've ever felt that books gave you a sense of belonging that real life didn't. The book is deeply sympathetic to that experience, and it doesn't mock it. You probably won't enjoy this if you need fast plot, if the diary format grates on you, or if you're looking for traditional fantasy action. Also, if you're sensitive to discussions of grief and family breakdown, the emotional undercurrent throughout the book may be heavier than you want. One practical note: the paperback edition from Little, Brown is the most common format. It's widely available through major retailers and bookshops. No special edition is required, though the cover art varies by region and some editions are nicer than others. I'd just recommend grabbing whatever copy is convenient rather than hunting for a specific version.
There's a follow-up novel called Home Again that continues Momo's story into her university years. It's longer, more sprawling, and structurally different. Some readers love it. Some don't. If you finish Among Others and want more, Home Again exists. But don't feel obligated to read it to understand the first book. The first novel is complete on its own terms.
