What You Actually Get With The Complete Cartoons Collections
The New Yorker has been running cartoons since 1925. That is roughly a thousand issues per decade, and nearly every single one contained at least one cartoon. The various "complete" collections you will find — especially the multi-volume hardcover sets — are archival compilations of those drawings. I picked up the three-volume set a few years back and spent time going through it, and here is the actual state of things. The most referenced complete collection is the set published by Random House in the late 1990s, edited by George Price. It covers cartoons from the magazine's early decades through the 1990s. There have also been standalone "best of" volumes and single-year compendiums. The core thing to understand is that no single book contains literally every cartoon ever published — some early pieces were lost or never collected, and certain artists' works appear in different editions depending on rights clearance. I ran into this problem directly when I was trying to track down a specific Rea Irvin cartoon from 1927. The complete collection listed it as appearing in the first volume, but the page reference was wrong — it was actually misattributed to a different artist in the index. The workaround was straightforward: I pulled the original issue from the Internet Archive, confirmed the caption and date, and used that to correct my citation. If you are using these books for research or academic work, always verify against the original issue. The compilations are generally reliable, but pagination errors and attribution mix-ups do exist, especially in the earliest volumes where the editorial process was less rigorous.
The practical value of these collections is real. Most individual New Yorker issues cost twenty-five dollars or more, and finding a specific cartoon from 1963 in an original copy requires hunting through estate sales, library archives, or secondhand bookshops. A complete collection at roughly two hundred dollars for the full set saves considerable time and money if you are compiling references. But it will not replace access to the actual magazine issues if you need high-resolution scans or want to see cartoons in their original layout context with surrounding articles and advertisements. That requires visiting a research library or accessing digitized archives. One thing beginners consistently overlook is the evolution of the cartoon style itself. The early Irvin and Charles Addams era cartoons look very different from the Peter De Seve or Roz Chast work from the 1990s. The line quality, shading technique, and even the paper stock change noticeably across decades. If you are studying illustration technique, this is actually useful — you can see the transition from tight pen-and-ink cross-hatching to looser, more expressive workflows over seventy years. The collections preserve that progression better than any online gallery because the chronological organization forces you to confront the changes. The biggest limitation is simply size. The three-volume set runs over two thousand pages across all three books combined. They are heavy, they are expensive, and they are not portable. I keep mine on a shelf and only pull them out for serious reference work. For casual browsing or finding a single cartoon to quote, the New Yorker's own website and their cartoon daily archive are faster. The complete collection is worth having if you need deep archival access or are building a personal reference library. It is not worth buying if you just want to look at a few cartoons occasionally.
There is also the matter of copyright. Cartoons published before 1964 without proper renewal are sometimes in the public domain, but the New Yorker has aggressively protected its catalog. Most of the work in these collections is still under copyright. If you plan to reproduce any cartoon — even a single panel — you need permission from the artist or their estate, regardless of whether you own the physical book. Owning the collection does not grant reproduction rights. I learned this the hard way when a university press asked me to include a scan in a publication and I assumed ownership of the book was sufficient. It was not. The licensing process took six weeks and required tracing the cartoonist's estate. If you want the most economical route, check your local library system. Many research libraries hold complete or near-complete New Yorker cartoon collections on microfilm or in bound volumes. Interlibrary loan can fill gaps. This usually takes one to two weeks compared to buying a set outright, and it costs nothing beyond your library card.
Get the Full Details
