Trying Donna Hay's Approach to High Tea at Home
I've spent more years than I care to count wrestling with afternoon tea spreads for houseguests and small gatherings. The whole ordeal usually ends up either overly fussy or painfully underwhelming. Donna Hay's method of approaching these things tends to sit somewhere in between — not quite traditional enough for purists, but practical enough that you can actually pull it off without losing your mind. That said, her High Tea Recipes Donna Hay collection on her website and in her books has a particular logic to it that most people miss until they've burned through a few batches. Donna's high tea framework is built around three pillars: savoury finger sandwiches, a standalone cake or two, and something sweet that isn't just another slice of sponge. She leans heavily on the idea that you should be able to assemble most of this the day before and still have it look presentable the next afternoon. That's not just lazy writing — it's genuinely how these things work in practice. The sandwich filling she recommends most often is cucumber with butter and sea salt, chicken with mayonnaise and watercress, and smoked salmon with cream cheese. The cucumber one sounds ridiculous until you understand that her method involves salting the slices first, wrapping them in paper towels, and letting them rest for twenty minutes. Without that step the bread goes soggy within an hour and you're staring at a wet mess nobody wants to touch. I learned that the hard way with a birthday party where three sandwiches ended up in the bin because I didn't bother with the salting. Now I just do it without thinking.
Her cakes tend toward the simple side — lemon drizzle, chocolate mud cake, pavlova. Nothing fancy. The reason this works is that when you're running a spread of six or eight items, the crowd doesn't want seven different cakes competing for attention. They want one good cake and a pile of small things they can nibble from. One thing Donna doesn't always make clear is that the timing between sandwich assembly and serving matters more than most people realize. If you're making these for a six o'clock high tea, you should have the sandwiches wrapped and refrigerated by four at the latest. Left out even for twenty minutes in a warm kitchen and the textures collapse. I had a client once complain that her sandwiches were "dissolving" at a corporate event, and it turned out the venue was sitting next to a radiator in July. We ended up moving everything to a chilled serving tray and it sorted itself out. For the sweet end, her raspberry shortbread and vanilla slice recipes get the most traction. The shortbread holds up well in a container and can be made three days ahead. The vanilla slice is trickier — the custard weeps if you cut it too early, so the rule is to pipe or spread the custard, top with pastry, chill, and only cut ten minutes before you need it. I keep a small offset spatula and a ruler at the ready for this because uneven cuts ruin the whole presentation regardless of taste.
If you're following the High Tea Recipes Donna Hay angle, the biggest mistake I see people making is treating the recipes as fixed formulas rather than templates. Her quantities are designed for four to six servings. Scale them up for twelve and the proportions shift in ways that aren't intuitive. A batch of sandwiches meant for six will need a noticeably thicker butter layer when you're feeding twelve, otherwise everything just sticks together. You adjust by increasing the butter by maybe twenty percent rather than doubling it outright. The other thing worth noting is that Donna's recipes assume you have a decent fridge and reasonable kitchen space. If you're working out of a shared apartment kitchen or a venue with limited refrigeration, a lot of the advance prep falls apart. I'd suggest making the cakes the day before and keeping them frozen until an hour before serving, and only assembling the sandwiches two hours out. That keeps the texture intact even in tight conditions. You can find her full recipe collection on donnahay.com.au under the events and entertaining section, and the same recipes appear in her book Entertaining. There isn't a dedicated downloadable PDF for high tea specifically — it's spread across a few posts and chapters. I've printed the relevant pages and keep them in a binder by my kitchen shelf. It's old school but it saves time when you're pulling this together on a Saturday morning.
Get the Full Details
